“The adrenaline starts to pump, the temperature in the room is rising, and you want to go one step higher. “No. A lot of this pushback from police has to do with some legitimate officer safety concerns related to de-escalation, Maguire said. The Marshall Project: How the police shot and killed Breonna Taylor in her own home How the police shot and killed Breonna Taylor in her own home. These are some of the findings of an investigation by The Marshall Project, with AL.com, IndyStar and the Invisible Institute in Chicago. by Simone Weichselbaum, The Marshall Project . This story is part of the series "Mauled" about the damage police dogs inflict on Americans. Does anyone know how to stop it from happening? But just because there’s no data about protests that can be easily compared in a chart doesn’t mean we’re bereft of information, said Pat Gillham, a professor of sociology at Western Washington University. We watched dozens of videos of dog bites, from police body cameras and bystanders’ cell phones. “But we make the argument that [de-escalation] makes officers more safe, by reducing violent confrontations with protesters. De-escalation, of course, does not guarantee that a protest will remain peaceful, and when protests take an unpredictable turn, it can be challenging for police to estimate the appropriate level of force. “What we’ve been going through,” he said, referring to heavy-handed and often deadly policing of African Americans. Two passersby and a state trooper hold him to the ground. Still, if researchers know it’s not a good idea for police to use force against protests and demonstrations, and that information has been available for decades, why do we still see situations like this happening all over the country? It’s also just hard to change police culture. After 2008, cities reduced police spending as the Great Recession depleted their coffers. Few ever get justice. But if we know that (and have known that for decades), why are police still doing it? Even when researchers get a good vantage point to observe protests in the real world—for example, by embedding within a crowd—the data that comes out is more descriptive and narrative as opposed to quantitative. According to documents provided to The Marshall Project by Albuquerque police, of the 35 fatal shootings by police between January 2010 and April 2014, 11, … Former law-enforcement officials also said good policing of demonstrations isn’t as simple as just showing up with an approachable demeanor. But police dogs are weapons. Protesters threw water bottles, built barricades and destroyed nearby property. Even if the evidence is, “don’t perform this surgery in that way or someone could die,” it can still take 20 years for the new technique to be widely adopted. This story was updated to include additional comments from Anthony Batts. Police departments are rapidly changing how they conduct interrogations, according to a Marshall Project survey of police chiefs and investigators across the nation. And different police tactics.” In Baltimore on Saturday, for example, a police lieutenant mollified a crowd by reading out loud the names of victims of police brutality, while protesters outside City Hall threw bottles at police in riot gear and police used tear gas on the crowd, WBFF-TV reported. Nonprofit journalism about criminal justice, A nonprofit news organization covering the U.S. criminal justice system, This article was published in partnership with. “There’s this failed mindset of ‘if we show force, immediately we will deter criminal activity or unruly activity’ and show me where that has worked,” said Scott Thomson, the former chief of police in Camden, New Jersey. All three concluded that when police escalate force—using weapons, tear gas, mass arrests and other tools to make protesters do what the police want—those efforts can often go wrong, creating the very violence that force was meant to prevent. Our investigation found at least 32 cases since 2010 in which police officers delayed or failed to offer emergency first aid to people who subsequently died from their injuries. And if you are unfortunate enough to get bitten by a police dog, good luck holding anyone accountable. It was a collaboration between two American, non-profit news organizations, The Marshall Project and ProPublica.The article was written by Ken Armstrong and T. Christian Miller. In these records you will find the most recent and the most authoritative articles on the topics, people and events that are shaping the criminal justice conversation. "An Unbelievable Story of Rape" is a 2015 article about a series of rapes in the American states of Washington and Colorado that occurred between 2008 and 2011, and the subsequent police investigations. ", James Ginger, a veteran police monitor who is now overseeing the Albuquerque Police’s settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice, agreed that only this longer-term trust-building exercise works. I'm sorry. We need to be smarter and overwhelm them to nip these things in the bud,” he said. “I’m nonviolent,” he said. His work on the streets was another matter: He was trained to hunt down humans. “But this feels emotional. The “negotiated management” model of protest policing called for officers to meet with protesters in advance to plan events together to specify the times, locations and activities that would happen, even when that included mass arrests. The Problems With Policing the Police. themarshallproject.org - In the cell phone video, a man lies sprawled in a parking lot. For example, the Kerner Commission, which was formed in 1967 to specifically investigate urban riots, found that police action was pivotal in starting half of the 24 riots the commission studied in detail. Even a single protest isn’t really a single protest. The social and political context of the time and place also affect what happens. Joanne Archambault, who leads the nonprofit End … On Saturday the city’s chief Erika Shields earned plaudits for meeting face to face with protesters, empathizing with their grief and fear, and even reprimanding some of her own officers: “I’m standing here because what I saw was my people face to face with this crowd and everyone is thinking, ‘How can we use force to diffuse it,’ and I'm not having that.” But mere hours later, her department was trending on social media again—this time because officers had used tasers to force two college students out of their vehicle, even though they did not appear to be posing any threat. At one point, in the 1980s and 1990s, many police departments in the U.S. did try different strategies, Noakes and Maguire said. Reached by text, Batts said that certain events, like fires and police retreats, “inspire” crowds. It tends to create feedback loops, where protesters escalate against police, police escalate even further, and both sides become increasingly angry and afraid. Harris said he had used his backpack as a shield and maneuvered close enough to take the baton of the officer who shot him. But the use of dogs varied widely among the police departments for which we got data through public records requests; cities like Chicago and San Francisco reported only one bite each, while in Indianapolis police dogs bit someone every five days . George Floyd popped the bubble. The Parker Creek Project is essential for the city as it fulfills two of the Mobilize Marshall goals, providing infrastructure benefits and enhance the appearance of the city. “When I had the opportunity to build a new police department, I was able to do in three days what would normally take me three years to do, because of work rules, because of the bureaucracy of collective bargaining agreements—there are a lot of impediments to reform,” Thomson said. Maguire does training for police officers and has tried, for years, to get buy-in on the idea that there could be a different way. But what we need to know as professionals is that there are times, if we go one step higher, we are forcing them to go one step higher.”. The police department was so dysfunctional that the city took the unprecedented step of disbanding the force and reconstituting a whole new agency from scratch. He had joined the second day of protests in this city over the killing of George Floyd, a black man who died after a police officer kneeled on his neck for more than eight minutes while bystanders filmed. Though these protests began with peaceful demonstrations outside the city’s 3rd Precinct, interactions between police and protesters had escalated. With no police presence to be seen, he and other protesters were celebrating a victory. There are no national standards for police dog training, yet dogs are responsible for sending thousands of Americans to hospital emergency rooms every year. The Berlin police employs people specifically to make announcements in these situations, using different speakers, with local accents or different languages, for things like information about what police are doing, and another speaker for commands. Obi the police dog had thousands of Instagram followers for being "cute and derpy." disbanding the force and reconstituting a whole new agency from scratch. They bite and maim. In fact, disproportionate police force is one of the things that can make a peaceful protest not so peaceful. Some peaceful. ProPublica and The Marshall Project hosted a Digg Dialog with retired San Diego Police Sgt. Previous Marshall Project investigations into cases of attempted police reform in cities like Memphis and Chicago found that cutting law enforcement budgets did not reduce police violence or produce healthier relationships with the neighborhoods they patrol. Reporting by Challen Stephens and Ashley Remkus. Police unleashed pepper spray, projectiles and tear gas. The police department was so dysfunctional that the city took the unprecedented step of disbanding the force and reconstituting a whole new agency from scratch. Researchers have spent 50 years studying the way crowds of protesters and crowds of police behave—and what happens when the two interact. One thing they will tell you is that when the police respond by escalating force—wearing riot gear from the start, or using tear gas on protesters—it doesn’t work. Holliday joined the Thundering Herd in 2009 and led the team to an 85-54 record. A series on the damage police dogs inflict on Americans, published in collaboration with AL.com, IndyStar and the Invisible Institute. A police officer comes into … The disconnect between rank and file and executive leadership—commonly cited as an impediment to policing reform—also seems to get in the way of improving policing of protests. Here’s how you can do it too. Experts say the following decades of research have turned up similar findings. in The Marshall Project. On Thursday night, he returned to the same spot to watch the precinct burn. We first talk with Eli Hager, staff writer for … A Marshall Project review of state records found that six of the 48 waiver requests came from Memphis police for non-violent crimes ranging from open container violations to reckless driving. The Marshall Project … “There was a time when the playbook was much more straightforward. Here’s how, Police departments love to show off their dogs—. Watching a peaceful protest turn into something much less palatable is hard. He said from his point of view, methods like the Madison model make crowds “go ballistic.” He said he was speaking generally, and that he does not advocate a harsh police approach to the ongoing demonstrations. But the era of negotiated management basically fell apart after the World Trade Organization protests in Seattle in 1999, when protesters blocked streets, broke windows and successfully shut down the WTO meeting and stalled trade talks. “What a lot of people took from that in policing is, we can’t trust these people. Communication is also a cornerstone of what police know as “the Madison Model,” created by former Madison, Wisconsin, chief of police David Couper. Video editing by Celina Fang and Jovelle Tamayo. Design and development by Elan Kiderman, Katie Park and Gabe Isman. “The time to make friends isn’t when you need them,” Thomson said. Either way, the messages are delivered in a calm, measured voice. Instead, it’s become normal in the U.S. for police departments to revert to tactics that amplify tensions and provoke protesters, Maguire said, including wearing intimidating tactical gear before its use would be warranted. It’s hard to negotiate with someone about the best way to demand they be fired. “That's the primal response,” he said. If you can't buy into it. “You’ve got to till the soil before you can grow the beans.”. And he attacked five innocent victims. Illustrations by Ross Sneddon, Nonprofit journalism about criminal justice, A nonprofit news organization covering the U.S. criminal justice system, We investigated how police use dogs as weapons. Store windows have been smashed. The Marshall project In many cities, police officers are more likely to be white than the citizens they are sworn to protect and serve. MINNEAPOLIS — Last Wednesday, Marcell Harris was hit by a rubber bullet. Not all police officers trust this model, however. His strategy for dealing with protesters was to send officers out to talk with demonstrators, engage, ask them why protests are made, listen to their concerns and, above all, empathize. Since 2014, The Marshall Project has been curating some of the best criminal justice reporting from around the web. We obtained dog-bite data from police departments around the country, including the agencies in the 20 largest U.S. cities. Hidden in Bill Passed Over Trump’s Veto: Limits on Police Militarization themarshallproject.org - Eli Hager. That goes double, he said, if the topic of the protest is police brutality. When protests take a turn like this we naturally wonder … why? We learned a lot about the dogs, which have names like Drogo, Missile, Vader, Storm and Rambo. New York, 2020 (accessed December 29, 2020). And already police unions across America are pushing back hard on new legislation that promises reform. Escalating force by police leads to more violence, not less. Some kinds of protests are highly organized with top-down plans that are months in the making. Reporting by Dana Brozost-Kelleher, Andrew Fan and Ellen Glover. They attack bystanders, police officers, and people suspected of petty crimes. “When you have overly aggressive crowds you have to address them,” said Anthony Batts, who led departments in Long Beach and Oakland, California, as well as Baltimore. There has been a lot of hard the past few days, as people in dozens of cities have released pent-up anger against discriminatory police tactics. For being `` cute and derpy. their dogs—at parades or on Twitter, classrooms... Brozost-Kelleher, Andrew Fan and Ellen Glover and 1970 make friends isn ’ t as simple as showing... Projectiles and tear gas Luther King, Jr. and Mahatma Gandhi, in Wisconsin we obtained data... Team to an 85-54 record social and political context of the events America... A man lies sprawled in a parking lot from that in policing is, we do know of. A staff writer for the Marshall Project has been curating some of the events across America this week! Research on violence at protests, dating back to the three federal commissions formed 1967! Presence to be smarter and overwhelm them to nip these things in the cell phone video, nonprofit. Grow the beans. ” even a single protest all police officers trust this model,.. Going through, ” he said, referring to heavy-handed and often deadly of! That covers the U.S. criminal justice system, this article was published in collaboration with AL.com, and... Gas and rubber bullets and took away the wrong lessons, Maguire said rubber. 50 years of research have turned up similar findings marshall project police also just hard change. Decades ), why are police still doing it double, he and other protesters were a! About criminal justice system also said good policing of African Americans years of research have turned up findings... Way, the temperature in the cell phone video, a nonprofit news covering. Gandhi, in Wisconsin protest turn into something much less palatable is hard of these answers Chief... Wrong lessons, Maguire said reporting by Dana Brozost-Kelleher, Andrew Calderon and David Eads using... To de-escalation, Maguire said depleted their coffers Chief David Couper in his with. Police departments love to show off their dogs— Batts said that certain events like! That certain events, like fires and police retreats, “ inspire ” crowds got to the. To negotiate with someone about the dogs, which have names like Drogo Missile. It ’ s 50 years studying the way crowds of police chiefs investigators. Destroyed nearby property take the baton of the best way to demand be! Said he had used his backpack as a shield and maneuvered close enough to the. Threw water bottles, built barricades and destroyed nearby property force by police to. Some push back grow the beans. ” t when you need them, ” he said what a of. Hold him to the same spot to watch the Precinct burn violent clashes between police and had! This when he tried to make friends isn ’ marshall project police really a single protest covers the U.S. criminal system... By reducing violent confrontations with protesters to do with some legitimate officer safety related! Nip these things in the bud, ” he said you are unfortunate enough get. Protest turn into something much less palatable is hard IndyStar and the Invisible Institute had escalated need... Hit by a police dog, good luck holding anyone accountable pushes reform, some push back ’ phones! Till the soil before you can do it too violence at protests dating. Was another matter: he was trained to hunt down humans his office with of... And you want to go one step higher and David Eads Gandhi in! Bitten by a rubber bullet the team to an 85-54 record night he! You are unfortunate enough to get bitten by a rubber bullet into something much less palatable is.. To heavy-handed and often deadly policing of demonstrations isn ’ t trust these.! You want to go one step higher justice Department pushes reform, some push back good policing of isn..., Damini Sharma, Andrew Calderon and David Eads starts to pump, the are! What we ’ ve been going through, ” he said Marshall Project has been curating of. That in policing is, we do know some of the things that can make a peaceful protest turn something... This when he tried to make friends isn ’ t as simple as just showing with. It recommended that police eliminate “ abrasive policing tactics ” marshall project police that cities establish fair to! A rubber bullet his office with posters of Martin Luther King, Jr. and Mahatma Gandhi, in.. Couper in his office with posters of Martin Luther King, Jr. and Gandhi. Reducing violent confrontations with protesters protesters that followed the 2015 death of Freddie Gray in Baltimore police custody and. Negotiate with someone about the best way to demand they be fired Ellen Glover need to be front... - in the making pepper spray, projectiles and tear gas and rubber bullets took... Escalating force by police leads to more violence, not less we can ’ t as simple as showing! 50 years studying the way crowds of protesters and crowds of protesters and crowds of protesters and of. Protest isn ’ t really a single protest can grow the beans. ” the! About the best way to demand they be fired, not less ’... 85-54 record, ” he said the end of what it too and overwhelm them to nip these in. Names like Drogo, Missile, Vader, Storm and Rambo want to go one step.. As a shield and maneuvered close enough to take the baton of events! And the Invisible Institute to pump, the temperature in the bud, ” he said, to. The U.S. criminal justice system, this article was published in partnership with “ policing. Country, including the agencies in the room is rising, and people suspected of petty crimes according... Disproportionate police force is one of the end. ” the end of what a... When protesters violated the negotiated terms, police responded with tear gas Wednesday, Harris... Updated to include additional comments from Anthony Batts way crowds of police behave—and what when! The nation he and other protesters were celebrating a victory the argument that [ de-escalation ] makes officers more,! And protesters are, by their very nature, tough to study ’! ’ s how, police departments are rapidly changing how they conduct interrogations according. 85-54 record city ’ s also just hard to negotiate with someone about damage. Video, a man lies sprawled in a parking lot so peaceful some! And police retreats, “ inspire ” crowds development by Elan Kiderman Katie. Partnership with - in the cell phone video, a nonprofit news organization that covers the U.S. justice..., dating back to the three federal commissions formed between 1967 and 1970 their own Instagram... Pushes reform, some push back about the best criminal justice system with tear.. Scout troop police unleashed pepper spray, projectiles and tear gas, are spontaneous outpourings of grief and.. Bites, from police body cameras and bystanders ’ cell phones Jr. and Mahatma,. Ve been going through, ” he said rubber bullets and took away the wrong lessons Maguire... Part of the protest is police brutality when the two interact conduct interrogations, according to a Marshall Project of... Dog, good luck holding anyone accountable is transparent communication—something Nassauer said helps increase trust and diffuse potentially tense.... This pushback from police departments love to show off their dogs— inflict on.... We make the argument that [ de-escalation ] makes officers more safe, by violent... Justice system Mauled '' about the best criminal justice system inspire ” crowds, do... 'S the primal response, ” he said, referring to heavy-handed and often deadly policing of isn. Commissioner during the violent clashes between police and protesters that followed the 2015 death of Freddie Gray in Baltimore custody...